How to Identify Mystery Faces in Old Family Photographs

Identifying old family photographs does not have to be impossible! Tips to identify your ancestors and discover your family history in old family photos.

Have you ever found yourself staring at old family photos, wondering who those unfamiliar faces might be? You’re not alone—unlabeled or mysterious photos are a common puzzle for genealogists. Thankfully, there are reliable strategies that can help turn those mystery individuals into identified ancestors. 

In the following tips, you’ll discover four proven methods to guide you through the process of uncovering the stories behind your old family photos, helping you unlock more of your family’s rich history.

Genealogy research, old family photos and mystery individuals in those photos seem to go hand in hand!

(But they don’t have to!)

The old family photographs I share in this post arrived in a box originally marked “Richardson”.   Unfortunately, none of the photographs are labeled. (I’m sure your ancestors labeled all of their photographs, right?!)

I do strongly suspect the men are from my Richardson family of Pittsylvania County, VA.  There is a certain family “look” I have come to recognize in known Richardson family photos.

However, there is the distinct possibility some of these men and women were just friends of the family or were some of my Elliott ancestors. Just because the photos were in the Richardson box does not a guarantee all of these people were Richardsons. Don’t trust you ancestor or relative’s organizational skills! After all, these photographs were stored in a trunk for approximately 80 years – 50 of those years in a southern Virginia barn!

So, how about you?

Do you have unknown photographs in your closet?  Still wondering how to even start identifying the people in those family photographs?

Why Identifying Unknown Family Photos Is Important

Identifying old family photos isn’t just about putting names to faces—it’s a vital step in piecing together your family’s story and understanding your heritage. Each photograph serves as a historical artifact, offering a glimpse into the lives of your ancestors, their relationships, and the communities they were part of.

By uncovering the identities behind these unknown faces, you can gain insights into family dynamics, cultural practices, and the social contexts in which your ancestors lived. For instance, a photo of a family gathering can reveal connections between distant relatives, helping you trace branches of your family tree that may have been overlooked. You might discover how different branches of the family interacted or even learn about occupations and hobbies that were significant to your ancestors, providing a fuller picture of their lives.

Additionally, the faces you uncover could unlock new leads for your research. Perhaps a photograph features a relative whose name you didn’t know—this could lead to finding additional records, such as birth or marriage certificates, that might have otherwise remained hidden. Identifying individuals in photographs can also help you break down those pesky brick walls in your research, as new connections often lead to new discoveries.

Taking the time to identify unknown family photos enriches your genealogy journey by adding depth to your family’s story, uncovering new research opportunities, and reconnecting you with your ancestral roots.

4 Proven Strategies to Identify Ancestors in Photos

Old family photos and mystery individuals often seem to go hand in hand. But they don’t have to! In this post, I’ll share my experience with a box of family photos labeled “Richardson,” none of which were actually labeled with names. 

While I suspect the men in the photos are from my Richardson family of Pittsylvania County, VA, there’s also a chance some of these individuals were just friends or other relatives.

If you’ve found yourself with a similar collection of unidentified photos, don’t worry—these four strategies will help you begin identifying the faces in your family’s history.

Tip #1 – Ask Relatives for Photo Identification

It may seem obvious, but one of the best ways to start is by asking family members.

Don’t limit your search to close relatives—reach out to distant cousins or collateral relatives. Sometimes, the answers to your photo mysteries come from unexpected branches of the family tree.

Share your photos with as many relatives as possible, even if it means doing some additional descendant research to track down living family members.

The more eyes you have on your unidentified family photographs, the greater the chance of someone recognizing the faces.

The photograph below is a good example of this concept.  This couple’s photograph sat for years in my unknown collection.

I was consulting a Richardson researcher about a different photograph when my break came. He  glimpsed this photograph and identified the couple as his grandparents Matthew and Edna (Richardson) Yeaman.  This Richardson researcher was from Alaska and is my third cousin twice removed.

Remember: No relative is too far in distance or location on the family tree not to potentially have information on your photographs.

Tip #2 – Use Social Media to Identify Family Photos

Social media is a powerful tool for genealogy research. Share your unidentified photographs in relevant Facebook groups, like those focused on genealogy, local history, or even groups specifically for your family’s surname. 

Examples of Facebook  groups for my Richardson photographs include  Pittsylvania County Genealogy, Virginia Genealogy, North Carolina Genealogy, U.S South Genealogy Research Community, and Halifax County, VA Genealogy and History. and received valuable feedback from people I had never met.

You can also create a photo album on platforms like Google Photos or Flickr, then share the link in various groups. This way, you avoid uploading each photo individually and give more people access to your collection. 

The larger the audience you reach, the better your chances of finding someone who can help.

Tip #3 – Free Websites for Unlabeled Family Photos

There are several dedicated websites that specialize in helping you identify old, unlabeled family photos. Sites like DeadFred.com allow you to upload your unidentified photos, where others can browse and potentially recognize faces.

You can also search by surname, location, or photographer’s name, which can sometimes yield surprising results.

In addition to DeadFred, consider exploring PhotoTree.com, which focuses on sharing historical photos and connects users with similar interests. 

These sites are free to use, making it easy to reach out for help. Remember to check back regularly, as new photos and potential matches are frequently added.

Tip #4 – How Google Image Search Identifies Ancestors

One of the most underused tools in genealogy photo research is Google Image Search. Upload your unidentified photograph into Google’s image search feature, and see if the same image appears somewhere else on the web.

You may be surprised to find that another family historian has already uploaded the same photo with additional information or even names.

While Google Image Search can feel like a shot in the dark, it’s worth trying, especially if the photograph has distinct features, like an unusual setting or background. With a bit of luck, you might stumble upon a website or blog post where your ancestor’s face is already identified.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Identifying Family Photos

Identifying old family photos can be rewarding, but it’s easy to make mistakes. Here are some common pitfalls to watch for:

1. Relying Too Heavily on Family “Looks”
While family traits can help in identification, they can also be misleading. Physical resemblances may skip generations, so use them as a starting point rather than a definitive identifier.

2. Assuming Everyone is from the Same Family Line
Don’t assume that all individuals in a photo come from the same family. Photos can easily get mixed up, including friends or neighbors. Always consider the possibility of unrelated individuals being present.

3. Overlooking Contextual Clues
Pay attention to details like clothing styles and backgrounds. These contextual clues can provide vital information about the people and help narrow down potential relatives.

4. Ignoring Collaboration
Don’t tackle the identification process alone. Reaching out to family members or distant cousins can provide new insights and valuable context that you may not have.

By being mindful of these common mistakes, you can enhance your process of identifying family photos. Keep an open mind and embrace the detective work—your family’s story is waiting to be uncovered!

FAQ: Answers to Common Questions About Identifying Old Family Photos

Q: How do I know if a photo is worth keeping if I can’t identify it?
It’s always worth keeping old family photos, even if they remain unidentified for years. You may not recognize the faces now, but future research or connections with distant relatives could solve the mystery.

Q: What if no one in my family recognizes the photos?
Expand your search! Use social media, genealogy groups, and specialized websites to reach a wider audience. You never know where a breakthrough might come from.

Q: Are there any tools or apps that can help me identify people in old photographs?

Yes! Several tools and apps can assist in identifying people in old photographs. Photo recognition software, like Google Lens or genealogy apps with facial recognition features, can help match faces to known individuals. Additionally, the photo dater at MyHeritage can indicate when a photograph was taken, narrowing down who could actually be in the photograph.

Do you have unknown photos in your collection?

Work through these four tips and start uncovering the stories behind the faces.

Share your progress in the comments below—I’d love to hear your success stories!

🤔Stuck trying to find an elusive ancestor? Ready to stop the aimless search of the genealogy databases that leaves you frustrated and still NO results?
Check out the VIP Genealogy Intensive Day where we focus on getting your genealogy research back on track with a day dedicated just to Y-O-U. 😊

You might be also be interested in:

• Top 10 Resources for Dating Old Photographs
• Case Study: 5 Tips to Identify A Family Photograph
• Tuesday’s Tip – How to Label a Photograph